

Creative Agency: Real Branding

-- Dan Gaffey, group account director, Real Branding


For the most part, this campaign resonates with the target market of the environmentally conscious public (specifically in California). My only criticism is that the concept behind the campaign is predictable. Don’t get me wrong, I am a granola-eating, Birkenstock-wearing tree-hugger who loves the idea of educating the public about energy conservation, but environmentalists and the public alike have become savvier than the concept behind this adver-game. However, I really like the fact that this site is firmly rooted in accomplishing its business objectives, such as tracking individual responses, bonus round plays, and time spent within each part of the application. With this kind of insightful data, it will be fascinating to see if users like in-depth, thinking questions or more playful games like my favorite, the simple “bald man laundry” game.
-- Ryan Buchanan, CEO and founder, eROI
This game works on every level. Assuming audiences found their way here (you'd have to be pretty darn convincing to get someone to play a game where they actually [gulp] learn something), they are in for a fun, engaging, and worthwhile experience. The appeal of the animated host is enough to get the kids excited, but the information that you can learn about saving money can get adults excited-- enough to make a change in their energy consumption habits. At the end of the day, that's what the campaign is going for, and it works. Interestingly enough, after spending the week in California, I've seen ads for this campaign/website on billboards on the highway. It piqued my curiosity then, and the game satisfied it now. I give it 4.5 out of 5 Energystars for getting the job done in spite of various restrictions that may have existed, possibly hampering creativity. Yeah, its a quiz, and we've seen that kind of execution a million times. But sometimes the most obvious execution is also the best, forcing the consumer to think just enough to act.
-- Ian Schafer, president, Deep Focus