Good for Mazda for embracing the video format in an online ad. Cars, in particular, are a high-bandwidth sell and auto-playing the video certainly draws the eye. Mazda takes it a step further by running a lifestyle-oriented clip here. It's an ambitious approach but one that tests the limits of what an online ad can do at this size. This DVD approach to an interactive video experience is now well-established and requires some careful asset planning. Putting a TV commercial in an ad unit feels a bit anachronistic these days. Though it's a charming concept, the details and story of the video get lost in this modest format. With such a generous investment in bandwidth, I would have liked some richer photography or deeper interaction. It's an intriguing car that invites a closer look.
-- Chad Currie, creative director, T3
When I first viewed the Mazda banner ad, I had the moment marketers' want all their audiences to have in an integrated campaign: "Ah, I remember that ad!" I had already seen it on TV and recognized it. For those who perhaps didn't see it elsewhere, the ad translates nicely to the web.
Dubbed "The Scramble," the ad used in this well-integrated campaign relies on the classic Chinese Fire Drill (no offense intended). The ad is clever and fun with a clear target audience -- families -- and an even clearer message about the product benefits: plenty of easy-to-use room. And the fact that it's so fun would make any parent feel like a kid again. Perfect video execution for the Zoom-Zoom brand.
We've seen banner ads with video way outperform other rich media tactics, so I expect that this ad performed well. Yet, a few minor usability issues could possibly stand in its way. The video relies heavily on the sound, and by the time I found the sound button, the ad was half over, so I replayed it and scrambled to hit the sound button in time.
The instructions on the side of the video referencing other clips were puzzling until I made it to the end of the video, or randomly clicked "skip intro." (For more novice users, a simple "more videos" link may have done the trick.) It reminded me that, just like on a website, more time spent with an ad isn't always better. If the user is spending that time trying to figure out how the ad works, it could be a disconnect.
I would have loved to see the fun and simplicity of the car come to life stronger in the actual banner interaction. Still, good product, good benefits and strong video make for a solid performance.
-- Kate Tomlinson, client services director, Ripple Effects Interactive