Diet Dr Pepper ad takes the cake

Diet Dr Pepper ad takes the cake
February 29, 2008
Our panelists review the latest banner from Diet Dr Pepper to find out just how sweet it really is.
Creative Notes
Firefox compatible
Campaign Details
Client: Cadbury Schweppes
Creative Agency: VML
Technology Vendor: PointRoll
Campaign Insight
Cadbury Schweppes offers users an interactive experience with its recent campaign for Diet Dr Pepper. To increase the household penetration of Diet Dr Pepper, the company created a banner ad, which boasts the product's "Nothing Diet About It" tagline. The ad allows users to customize their own decadent Diet Dr Pepper cake. The banner features tools such as a pastry bag filled with frosting, candles and letters.

After users decorate their Diet Dr Pepper cake, they can share their decorated cake with friends.

Robert Stone, interactive manager for Cadbury Schweppes Americas Beverages noted, "We wanted to educate consumers that not all diet soft drinks require a taste sacrifice. We feel this is a great extension of our offline campaign and carries the overall thematic very well." 
-- Nanette Marcus, cover stories editor, iMedia Connection

Editor's Note
Creative Showcase is meant to be a teaching tool and an inspiration for our readers. We comment only on creative that we really love. Our panelists discuss what makes it great, but if they feel there were missed opportunities that would have made it better, we invite them to mention those. And finally, we seek out a wide range of opinions that reflect the marketplace for the panel, in order to provide constructive, useable feedback for agencies, clients and others involved in these creative pieces.
The Panel
Sometimes we forget that the internet is fun. It's irreverent. Although we now spend most of our days as tools to the corporate dictate, every now and then someone sends us something that makes us smile. The mistake that most marketers make is that they go for that irreverence without any connection to their brand.

This campaign succeeds in avoiding that trap. Here's how. It's Diet Dr Pepper and it conveys the taste of the product through the cake. We almost lick our lips thinking of cake. That, in itself, would have made it a success. The idea of taste is probably one of the most difficult things to convey through the web. But it also encourages interaction in a way that enables brand awareness. Although it's a cake, you are really decorating a Dr Pepper logo. Your primary interaction -- your focus when interacting with the creative -- has you focus right on that.

Now, if they're only smart enough to run it on Facebook targeted around people's friend's birthdays, anniversaries, etc., then they'll have closed the loop on the other side with the media. So, my birthday was this month. Where's my Diet Dr Pepper cake?
-- Sean X Cummings, director of marketing, Ask.com

Birthdays are magical times. You feel warm and fuzzy, people acknowledge you in a special way, and there's almost always some cake involved. What better way for Diet Dr Pepper to win attention, associate the product and prompt interaction with its creative? It feels about as natural as any other soda commercial motif.

There are several things to like about this expandable execution. The fact that it features a rollover-to-expand is one of them, because only a portion of the unit, the left third that contains the call-to-action, triggers the expanding panel. Requiring a click-to-expand would not have yielded results, and making the entire unit sensitive to [accidental] rollover would have inflated the results and annoyed uninterested users.

Upon expanding, you can decorate a birthday cake and send it to a friend. The cake is, of course, branded Diet Dr Pepper, which is also easy to mask with the supplied icing tool. In addition, one could, in theory, send a very "unbirthday" message to someone using the text box tool. Aside from brand association "what-ifs," the viral payoff is what really gives the creative legs -- otherwise, who wants to decorate their own cake? The only real letdown from a user perspective happens if your mouse travels outside the expanded panel before you've typed your friend's email. If so, I hope you didn't spend too much time on your masterpiece, because once the panel closes and your customized cake disappears, you may not bother to start over, your friend may not get their birthday treat, and Diet Dr Pepper's pass-along rates may not be what they could have been. Better if the panel stayed open until the user hits the close button. With rich media campaigns, thoughtful coding is more than just icing on the cake.
-- Rob Tucker, founder, rt interactive

Footnote: Submissions are judged by a panel of industry experts from and based on the following criteria: how the creative captures the specific customer; how it meets the brand's business needs; impact of execution; and creativity. If you would like your creative considered for Creative Showcase, send an email to creative@imediaconnection.com.
 

Comments

Dean Donaldson
Dean Donaldson March 3, 2008 at 6:07 AM

All advertising is intrusive in nature - it is a way of getting people to stop and think - "hey have you considered this" whilst they are in the middle of something else. There are all sorts of factors that will work for and against this - behavioural targeting will not sort them all - and neither will reducing the area of expansion to one-third or even a click or worse, a time-delay (which resets on user roll-off, roll back-on). Rich media used to be justified by high-clicks and high-intrusiveness so I welcome smart innovations to address this. Take for example Eyeblaster. They have introduced something called 'velocity tracker'. It works to address publishers need to attract interaction on accidental roll-over which may and can cause a user to react positively, but does so by measuring the speed of a mouse passing through the creative before triggering a response. This way it notices someone passing-through and stopping or passing-through and leaving - it works ‘with' the user – and can avoid accidental roll-over all together. More than that it can even save the context between expansions so roll-off-on will not restart the entire animation sequence if a user chooses to re-roll! It is the most powerful and intelligent user-centric solution out there for striking a balance between accidental and calculated roll-over...

Rob Tucker
Rob Tucker February 29, 2008 at 12:48 PM

Thanks for the comments, Garlin & David. It is responsible of Pointroll to discount accidental rollovers in the reporting, and it makes sense. I'm also sure Cadbury Schweppes minimized the effect of this in the way the unit was coded, which was also smart. I totally hear you both on the publisher specs, but it would have been nice if there was a way to auto-save what the user was working on (in the browser cache) so, if he/she accidentally moused off of the unit, the session could be continued once the pointer returned. Not sure if that was explored.

Erik Johnson
Erik Johnson February 29, 2008 at 12:40 PM

I heart Technical Chocolate

David Kegel
David Kegel February 29, 2008 at 10:27 AM

I am not sure the connection between cake and Dr. Pepper is really presented strong enough. Both sweet, but a treat, but something about birthdays threw me. And a response to Robert Tucker, publishers require that panels close after you roll off. This is not an issue of good code.

Garlin Smith
Garlin Smith February 29, 2008 at 10:26 AM

I wanted to reply to Rob's comments on the functionality of the Pointroll rich media expandable ad for Dr. Pepper. He's dead-on regarding the fact that 'rollover to expand' greatly outperforms 'click to expand' functionality (5.5% vs .5% User Interaction Rate on average). 'Accidental rollover' is actually taken into account at Pointroll, interactions that last under 1 second are not included in the advertiser's reporting. Also, the majority of publishers require expandable ads to close when a user rolls off these very popular and effective ads, unless there is some type of form being filled out, game being played or some other customized content that would be lost if the ad closed. Pointroll works very closely to adhere to publishers specs but also work with them to get exceptions made where it makes for a good user/advertiser/publisher experience.