In Focus

Anatomy of a winning pitch

Introduction

Recently, our team at Basement was involved in one of the more unique experiences I've had in my career: an "Agency Shoot-out," which took place at the iMedia Entertainment Summit, in Beverly Hills.

The concept was direct enough: two agencies compete in a head-to-head pitch for a fictitious project based around the film "Casablanca." What gave it a reality-show spin was the pitch environment -- live in front of several hundred people at the Summit.

Five prestigious judges (Don Buckley, SVP, interactive marketing, Warner Bros.; Dwight Caines, EVP, Worldwide digital marketing strategy, Columbia TriStar Marketing Group; Hilary Hattenbach, VP, digital marketing, Twentieth Century Fox; Doug Neil, SVP, digital marketing, Universal Pictures; Amy Powell, SVP, interactive marketing, Paramount Pictures) were on hand to deliver critiques of each team's approach. Pretty naked stuff.

And pretty fantastic results, from both Basement and our competitors, MindComet. Thanks to a fantastic effort from my ace team at Basement, we won the pitch. Thus, I'm here to share the marketing strategy and creative thinking that brought us victory.

But before we get into what we did, let's review the challenge.

 

Comments

jen vill
jen vill June 22, 2010 at 5:57 PM

Good job, Doug!Your presentation is very nice and and very impressive(i.e. social networking! You just deserved what you've got with your team.

Marcy Pellegrino
Marcy Pellegrino August 13, 2008 at 2:06 PM

Fabulous!

Doug Schumacher
Doug Schumacher July 22, 2008 at 6:51 PM

Thanks for your comments. It's always nice to get feedback, especially when complimentary ;)

Randolph, to answer your question about what worked for us, I think it was strategic relevance throughout the various tactics.

We spent a fair amount of our presentation identifying the target audience and outlining what would appeal to them. Basically trying to demonstrate that we knew what they were about, and what would appeal to them.

That strategic foundation is a key part of our process for real projects, and so we applied it to Casablanca, as well.

Once the strategy is tight, it really guides the concepts, the language, the designs, etc.

Of course, strategies have to be brought to life, and I'm very proud of the job our creative team did towards that end.

Randolph Price
Randolph Price July 21, 2008 at 5:16 PM

Thanks for sharing the presentation so that anyone wanting to walk through it could (as I did!).

Great stuff!

What I was wondering from a learning standpoint is .... why did you win versus your competitor? (not to be negative and I am sure Mindcomet did a great job but can you identify what was the difference?

Was it your approach/methodology? Ideas? Integrated Approach?

marc meyer
marc meyer July 21, 2008 at 1:35 PM

I was very very impressed by this. I'm going to throw the slides up on my blog. I particularly liked the social media spect of it.

Victoria Rich
Victoria Rich July 21, 2008 at 11:26 AM

Great job Doug and team - Enjoyed the strategy development and synopsis - especially the social networking concept!