In Focus

4 reasons websites are becoming irrelevant

Sign 1

Mobile-social utilities

We have reached a watershed moment in mobility. With the launch of iPhone OS 3.0 and Apple's new 3Gs, the U.S. is now playing catch-up in the world of mobile computing. (As many of you know, the U.S. lags behind many other nations when it comes to mobile adoption.)

The barriers to entry for owning an iPhone (or any smartphone) have been lowered, and the benefits of a true mobile OS have been realized by the mass market. For marketers, the question is not, "Do we leverage the iPhone?" Rather, the question is, "How should we leverage the iPhone to serve our overarching brand strategy, and what other devices should we consider?" Any attempt to answer this question must start by asking another question: "How can we deliver value?" (I know you should not answer a question with a question -- just humor me.)

Dunkin' Donuts recently took a run (pun intended) at a value-driven iPhone application. The obvious application -- a Dunkin locator -- would not have been an innovative use of technology and would have added little consumer value beyond what current tools can add. Realizing this, a decision was made to create something that did not exist before for Dunkin -- something valuable that would make the purchase process easier and more fun.

Dunkin' Donuts created the "Dunkin Run" platform, accessible via web or iPhone.

What makes this idea work is not the technology. This idea works due to the way Dunkin' Donuts employs social influence. This initiative attempts to position "Dunkin Runners" as social heroes.

This video explains how you can be an office hero.

This initiative is, in my opinion, of greater value to Dunkin' Donuts consumers than a website could ever be. Dunkin customers may still go to DunkinDonuts.com for information, but "Dunkin Run" is far more compelling and functional.

 

Comments

Adam Broitman
Adam Broitman August 30, 2009 at 6:51 PM

Bruce

Great question. I think the answer requires a post unto itself.

(my next one perhaps?).

What are your thoughts?

Adam Broitman
Adam Broitman August 30, 2009 at 6:50 PM

Walter

Thanks for the comment!

I do not think that it is about brand surrender at all. I believe that brands are designed internally, dispatched and fully formed through the ongoing interactions between the brand and it's consumers.

Some say that brands have lost control. I think that is nonsense. Brands will only lose control if they surrender it--that said, a brand is always going to be defined, in part, by the conversation that surrounds it.

Walter Adamson
Walter Adamson August 30, 2009 at 2:47 AM

I thought that I kind of knew this, but your examples and article made it very very concrete for me. I have to now go do some things you've set off in my mind.

Also, your "our brand is what people say it is" - that's "brand is brand behavior" right? But doesn't mean that companies "surrender" their brand to the masses - it means they understand how it participates and contributes and "behaves" - am I on the right track here?

Thanks, Walter Adamson @g2m

bruce kuehnle
bruce kuehnle August 25, 2009 at 4:36 PM

What is the future of Mobi websites ?

Adam Broitman
Adam Broitman August 19, 2009 at 9:41 PM

Mark

Thanks for the comment and the validation. It is so great to get comments that are a reminder that, I am not alone in my thinking and that others are out there fighting the same fight.

Cheers

Mark Peesel
Mark Peesel August 19, 2009 at 1:23 PM

This is very good info. I've been in internet marketing for more than 13 years and I really don't build websites anymore. Most people have websites and if they call me to say they want a new one, my first question is "why?". Usually they say because they're not getting the traffic, orders, leads, exposure they think they need. 9 times out of 10, the problem isn't the website. It's how it's being used, marketed, promoted, updated, and it's standing or influence within the community, etc.

As an example, you may have a really great product with a really cool phone number, but if no one knows about your phone number, no one will call.

I agree with about everything you say in that it's the experience and conversation that counts. I think you are right on with the term "social influence" and how DD uses it and that it's so important to have that strong social influence to make a difference.

Thanks for the great article.

Mark
"it's all about the conversation"

Adam Broitman
Adam Broitman August 11, 2009 at 6:45 PM

Thanks Barrett--with all the noise out there, sometimes you need provocative to cut through so people hear signal--I am glad you enjoyed the signal!

Barrett Rossie
Barrett Rossie August 11, 2009 at 6:31 PM

Adam, just a thank you for a GREAT point of view. I love the BooneOakley, Skittles and Modernista sites. What web sites are supposed to be, to do, to represent changes constantly. Provocative title aside, this is a great read.

Rick L'Amie
Rick L'Amie August 10, 2009 at 3:40 PM

Adam,

These are inspiring ideas. We don't have to chase the latest shiny object that seems to change every 20 minutes or we'll lose our focus and forget what we are supposed to be doing as marketers in the first place. But we do need to be innovative and these are incredibly innovative examples. Thanks for sharing them.

David Schultz
David Schultz August 10, 2009 at 2:51 PM

Seems like kind of sensationalist title for your article, considering a few paragraphs in you soften your stance "I am not saying that brands no longer need websites".

Adam Broitman
Adam Broitman August 10, 2009 at 1:19 PM

Scott

Good point. Text based information certainly has it's place--but in terms of providing a branded experience--it's place is changing. That is really what I was driving at with that statement.

Scott Kolber
Scott Kolber August 10, 2009 at 1:16 PM

Please don't be so dismissive of "text-based information," as you seem to do in the last paragraph of this otherwise interesting article (text-based, by the way). Simple, concise text on a website is an extremely efficient way to provide good customer service and support a brand. Ever try to find useful information on an ad agency's website? They're generally useless showcases of self indulgent design that provide no information and are impossible to navigate. Useful information is a good thing when communicated through well written text.

Adam Broitman
Adam Broitman August 10, 2009 at 12:39 PM

Memo

Great account people are what is all comes down to--without them, it is often times hard to sell these things through.

A

Guillermo Corea
Guillermo Corea August 10, 2009 at 12:30 PM

Thanks for all the samples you gave throughout your article. From my perspective though, one big bump is getting clients to understand these new realities. The sample that you gave of Tacobell is perfect. Like you, I don't have a reason for visiting the Tacobell website. However, an app that lets me order something that I can then pick up at the nearest restaurant to my current GPS location is something I would use.

Adam Broitman
Adam Broitman August 10, 2009 at 9:55 AM

Good point Kevin C. But applications are slowly invading the TV screen and screens of various sizes.

Again, I am not saying the website is dead (especially not for ecommerce) but as a branded experience, the nature of the website is changing.

Thanks for challenging me--that is why I write these things.

Kevin Conway
Kevin Conway August 10, 2009 at 9:48 AM

Your premise is based on a very narrow brand application. Maybe for location finder and ordering food, i.e. Dunkin DOnuts. But, a web site that depends on images for selling products like Art Galleries, Collectibles, photgraphy,e tc, etc a mobile 2x3" screen just doesn't cut it.

Adam Broitman
Adam Broitman August 10, 2009 at 9:22 AM

Kevin

I certainly agree. We battled about the title of this article, and at the end of the day--you know, if it bleeds it leads :)

In all seriousness, I wanted to be provocative with the title, but I certainly feel that brand websites will never go away, they will just change their role.

Anyhow, glad you enjoyed the article, excited to be on the breakthrough board with you and--if you like Augmented Reality, my agency launched an AR app today for A&E; have a look:

http://www.aetv.com/5-lives-of-criss-angel/5-lives-augmented-reality/

a video of it is here as well--

http://circ.us/clients/ae-television-networks/

Kevin Doohan
Kevin Doohan August 10, 2009 at 9:17 AM

Totally agree with marketers needing to keep an eye on the future and the areas called out for focus here are good ones in my opinion. The Dunkin example is well done and I'm particularly enthralled these days with that augmented reality TAT video.

I think though, today, that the brand website is not diminishing in value. It is simply being complemented by all this other stuff. The brand website still needs to be awesome. Losing even a little focus on your brand website while building something super-cool with far less reach could be a mistake.